The Reflex That Outlived Its Purpose

It arrives without permission. One moment you are mid-sentence at dinner, the next a sharp jolt seizes the floor of your chest, jerks the air in your throat, and produces that absurd, percussive syllable: hic. You did not decide to do it. You cannot decide to stop it. You can hold your breath, drink from the wrong side of the glass, let a friend startle you, and still the thing keeps firing on its own private schedule.

The hiccup belongs to a small and humbling category of bodily events: actions your body performs without consulting you, and which you cannot override by act of will. You can hold your breath, but only until your brainstem overrules you. You can blink on command, but you cannot truly stop blinking. The hiccup is stranger still, because unlike breathing or blinking it serves no obvious function in an adult human at all. It does not protect you. It does not help you eat, sleep, or survive. It simply happens, sometimes for minutes, occasionally for far longer, and then it stops as mysteriously as it began.

For most of recorded medicine, physicians had no idea what hiccups were for or how to reliably end them. The remarkable thing is that, two and a half thousand years after Hippocrates, this remains broadly true. We now have a credible story about where the hiccup comes from, a story that reaches back hundreds of millions of years into the evolutionary past. What we still do not have is a single home remedy proven to work. The hiccup, as one description has it, is a reflex in search of a purpose.

The anatomy of a spasm

To understand why a hiccup is so stubborn, it helps to watch one happen in slow motion. The whole event is a piece of involuntary choreography involving two structures that almost never act together.

The first is the diaphragm, the broad dome of muscle slung beneath the lungs that does the quiet work of breathing. In an ordinary breath it descends smoothly, drawing air into the chest. In a hiccup it does something violent instead. It contracts in a sudden, sharp spasm, yanking a gulp of air downward with far more force than any normal inhalation.

The second structure is the glottis, the gap between the vocal cords. Roughly thirty-five milliseconds after the diaphragm fires, the cords slam shut, abruptly choking off the inrushing air ¹. That snap of closing tissue against a column of moving air is what produces the sound. The noise is not the spasm itself; it is the body slamming a door on the breath the spasm just started. The entire signature of a hiccup, the part everyone can imitate, is over in a fraction of a second.

The medical name for the condition is singultus, from a Latin word meaning a sob or a gasp, which is a fair description of how the body behaves during a long fit. A single bout of hiccups can involve thousands of these spasms. Clinicians describe normal fits running into the low thousands of contractions before they subside on their own. That is a great deal of involuntary effort spent on something with no apparent point.

And the fit can run far longer than a few thousand. The extreme case belongs to Charles Osborne, an Iowa farmer who, by the standard account, began hiccuping in 1922 and did not stop for sixty-eight years ². He hiccuped through two marriages, raised children, and lived an otherwise ordinary life, all while his diaphragm convulsed at intervals that reportedly added up to hundreds of millions of spasms over his lifetime. Doctors examined him for decades. None of them could explain the cause, and none could make it stop. The hiccups finally ceased on their own in 1990, a year before he died. If a hiccup were merely a passing muscle twitch, it should not be able to do that. Its persistence points to something deeper than a flutter in the diaphragm.

The looping nerve

The diaphragm does not move on its own. It takes its orders from a single, oddly designed nerve called the phrenic. And the phrenic nerve is where the hiccup begins to look less like a malfunction and more like a relic.

The phrenic nerve carries the signal that tells the diaphragm when to contract. What makes it peculiar is its route. Rather than running a short, sensible path from chest to chest, it originates high up in the neck, around the third to fifth cervical vertebrae, and then travels a long way down through the chest to reach the muscle it controls. That circuitous geography is a clue. In the body, when a nerve takes an inexplicably long detour, it is often because evolution built the circuit for a different animal in a different era and then never bothered to redraw the plan.

The command itself comes from deeper still. Reflex circuits like this one are governed not by conscious thought but by the brainstem, the ancient core of the nervous system that handles breathing, heartbeat, and other things you would never want to manage by hand. The mid-twentieth-century neurosurgeon Wilder Penfield, famous for mapping the surface of the human brain by stimulating it in conscious patients, helped establish how much of our involuntary behavior is hardwired into these lower structures ³. Later researchers traced the hiccup specifically to a so-called hiccup center sitting deep in the medulla, the part of the brainstem furthest from anything resembling a decision. This is why willpower fails so completely. The circuit that fires a hiccup sits below the level at which you have any say.

So there is a long, strangely routed nerve and a primitive control center buried in the oldest part of the brain, both dedicated to a reflex that does nothing useful. That combination invites an obvious question. If the hiccup is so deeply built into us and so useless, where did it come from?

A leftover from the water

In 2003, a team led by the physiologist Christian Straus in Paris offered an answer that reframed the whole problem ⁴. The hiccup, they proposed, is not a glitch at all. It is a fossil. Specifically, it is a leftover motor pattern inherited from the animals from which we descend, animals that breathed not air but water.

The argument runs like this. Look closely at the neural sequence of a hiccup, the sharp inspiratory contraction followed by an abrupt closure of the glottis, and it bears an uncanny resemblance to the way certain early air-breathing vertebrates and their living relatives move water and air across their gills. Creatures caught in the transition between water and land, like the ancestors of modern amphibians, used a pumping motion to draw fluid in and then snap a flap shut to keep it out of their primitive lungs. Contract the throat, pull in the water, close the glottis so the water does not flood the airway. The rhythm is nearly identical to the one your diaphragm and vocal cords perform when you hiccup at the dinner table.

You can still see the ancestral version of this behavior in a tadpole. A tadpole gulps water and air using the same basic neural rhythm, a coordinated push-and-close that is, in evolutionary terms, the hiccup’s direct cousin. The wiring that once served gill ventilation, Straus and colleagues argued, was never deleted when our lineage moved onto land and switched to lungs. It was simply repurposed and partly silenced, left dormant in the brainstem where it can still misfire. By this reckoning the circuit is something on the order of 370 million years old, a piece of machinery older than dinosaurs, older than the first trees, running quietly inside a creature that has not breathed water for a very long time.

It is a slightly vertiginous idea. We hiccup, on this account, because our ancestors once breathed underwater, and evolution is a tinkerer that keeps old parts in the drawer rather than throwing them away. The theory has not been proven in the way a drug trial proves a medicine, and it remains a hypothesis about deep history rather than settled fact. But it does something valuable. It explains why a useless reflex would be so stubbornly, deeply wired into us. You cannot will away a hiccup for the same reason you cannot will away your own evolutionary inheritance.

The rehearsal in the womb

If the fish-ancestor theory explains why the circuit exists, it leaves a second puzzle untouched. Adults hiccup occasionally and pointlessly. But human babies hiccup constantly, and they begin before they have ever drawn a breath of air.

Fetuses hiccup in the womb, sometimes for a meaningful fraction of their time, weeks before their lungs will ever inflate ⁵. Mothers feel the rhythmic thump. On ultrasound the small body jolts in the familiar pattern. Whatever a hiccup is doing there, it cannot be a reaction to eating too fast or laughing too hard. The fetus is doing it in the dark, submerged, with no air to gulp at all. That fact suggests the reflex is not merely a vestige we are stuck with but something that might serve a purpose precisely at the start of life.

In 2019, a team led by Lorenzo Fabrizi at University College London set out to watch what a hiccup does to a newborn’s brain ⁶. They placed gentle electrodes on the scalps of sleeping infants and recorded the electrical activity that followed each hiccup. The result was striking. Every hiccup triggered a large, distinctive wave of activity that swept across the brain’s cortex, the outer sheet of tissue responsible for processing sensation and, eventually, for conscious control.

The researchers proposed that this is no accident. The hiccup, they suggested, may be a tool the developing brain uses to learn its own body. Each contraction of the diaphragm sends a clear, isolated signal upward, and the brain registers it, mapping the muscle to the sensation it produces. In effect the infant is calibrating the link between the muscles of breathing and the brain that will one day need to command them. The hiccup becomes a rehearsal, a way of laying down the neural map before the real performance of breathing begins.

If that is right, then the hiccup is two things at once. It is an ancient circuit inherited from water-breathing ancestors, and it is a developmental tool that the human brain has quietly press-ganged into service at the very beginning of life. The old reflex did not just survive. It found a new job, at least for a few months, before settling into the useless, occasional nuisance it remains for the rest of our years.

The honest answer at the dinner table

Which brings us, at last, to the question everyone actually wants answered. How do you make them stop?

Here the science turns embarrassingly thin. The folk pharmacopoeia is enormous: hold your breath, drink water upside down, swallow a spoonful of sugar, breathe into a paper bag, pull your knees to your chest, have someone frighten you, pull on your tongue. Each of these has a plausible-sounding rationale. Holding your breath raises the level of carbon dioxide in the blood, which may dampen the reflex. Folding your knees against your chest puts mechanical pressure on the diaphragm. Swallowing dry sugar or tugging the tongue stimulates the vagus nerve, a major conduit between the gut, the throat, and the brainstem. All of these maneuvers share a single underlying logic: interrupt the looping nerve signal long enough to break the rhythm.

The logic is reasonable. The evidence is almost nonexistent. Virtually none of these remedies has survived a properly designed controlled trial, and there is no home cure that medicine can honestly recommend as proven ⁷. The reason this matters, and the reason everyone is so confident their personal trick works, comes down to a quiet statistical illusion.

Most hiccup fits end on their own within a few minutes. So whatever you happen to be doing when the hiccups stop will appear to be the thing that stopped them. You drink the upside-down water; the fit ends thirty seconds later; you conclude, reasonably enough, that the water worked. But the fit was going to end anyway. The remedy was a passenger, not a driver. We confuse coincidence for cure, over and over, and the abundance of competing folk remedies is itself a symptom of the fact that none of them reliably works. If any single trick truly conquered hiccups, we would not need a hundred others.

There is one part of the picture that is genuinely clinical, and worth knowing. When hiccups persist beyond roughly forty-eight hours, they cross from nuisance into symptom ⁸. Prolonged or intractable hiccups can be a sign that something is irritating the long phrenic nerve or the brainstem circuit it answers to: acid reflux, a tumor pressing on the nerve, certain medications, and in rare cases even a stroke. For these patients, doctors do have real tools, including muscle relaxants and drugs that calm overactive nerve signaling. But that is a different animal from the fit that seizes you over dinner and vanishes before dessert. For the ordinary hiccup, the only honest prescription is patience.

What you are remembering

There is something quietly consoling in all of this. The hiccup is one of the few experiences modern medicine cannot fully tame, and the reason is not that we are missing some clever trick. The reason is that the hiccup is older than almost everything else about us. It runs on a circuit assembled for a body that breathed water, kept on for a brain that needed to learn its muscles, and then never switched off.

So the next time a hiccup ambushes you and refuses every remedy you throw at it, you might reconsider what is actually happening. You are not malfunctioning. You are not doing anything wrong. A control center deep in the oldest part of your brain has, for no reason it can explain, replayed a 370-million-year-old rhythm your lineage stopped needing before it ever crawled onto land. You cannot stop it because you were never meant to be in charge of it. You are not breaking. You are remembering.

Sources

1. Straus, C. et al., “A phylogenetic hypothesis for the origin of hiccough,” BioEssays, 2003. — https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/bies.10224
2. Whitelaw, W. A., “Charles Osborne and the longest attack of hiccups,” BMJ, 1990. — https://www.bmj.com/content/300/6731/1036
3. Penfield, W. and Jasper, H., Epilepsy and the Functional Anatomy of the Human Brain, Little, Brown and Company, 1954. — https://archive.org/details/epilepsyfunction0000penf
4. Straus, C. et al., “A phylogenetic hypothesis for the origin of hiccough,” BioEssays, 2003. — https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12655636/
5. Kahrilas, P. J. and Shi, G., “Why do we hiccup?” Gut, 1997. — https://gut.bmj.com/content/41/5/712
6. Whitehead, K., Jones, L., Fabrizi, L. et al., “Event-related potentials following contraction of respiratory muscles in pre-term and full-term infants,” Clinical Neurophysiology, 2019. — https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1388245719312726
7. Steger, M., Schneemann, M., Fox, M., “Systemic review: the pathogenesis and pharmacological treatment of hiccups,” Alimentary Pharmacology & Therapeutics, 2015. — https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/apt.13374
8. Hosoya, R. et al., “Analysis of factors associated with hiccups using the FAERS database,” Pharmaceuticals, 2022. — https://www.mdpi.com/1424-8247/15/1/27

Related reading

• The Stranger on the Voicemail
• The Sound of Someone Else Eating

More from the Body edition →